Posted on February 15, 2011 in DUI

San Francisco DUI Attorney Paul Burglin has persuaded a second Superior Court judge in Marin County to order the DMV to grant his client an Ignition-Interlock restricted driver's license. Judge Lynn Duryee and Judge Verna Adams of the Marin County Superior Court have now both ruled in favor of Burglin's clients that the new IID-restricted license law effective July 1, 2010, applies to individuals with violation dates prior to July 1, 2010.

If you are a second or third time DUI offender interested in obtaining an IID-restricted license, contact San Francisco DUI attorney Paul Burglin today at (415) 453-0534.

RULING February 1, 2011

The petition for writ of mandate is granted. Applying its independent judgment, as articulated in Association of Irritated Residents v. San Joaquin Valley Unified Air Pollution Control Dist. (2008) 168 Cal.App.4th 535, 542-543 and Yahama Corp. of America v. State Bd. Of Equalization (1998) 19 Cal.4th 1, 7-8, the court finds that the July 1, 2010 amendment to Vehicle Code section 13352, subdivision (a)(3) applies to Petitioner. The effect of that amendment is to reduce the civil penalty by allowing a convicted driver to seek a restricted license after serving 90 days of the two-year suspension rather than 12 months of the suspension. “…What was said [in In re Estrada (1965) 63 Cal.2d 740] with regard to an amendatory statute lessening criminal punishment equally applies to the reduction or elimination of civil penalties or forfeitures." (People v. Durbin (1966) 64 Cal.2d 474, 479.) Respondent shall grant Petitioner an IID-restricted license upon satisfaction of the conditions specified in section 13353, subdivision (a)(3).

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on February 07, 2011 in DUI

May the Police Lawfully Stop A Motorist Based Solely On Somebody Reporting a Drunk Driver?

The key to beating a DUI charge in San Francisco---or at least getting a reduced offer on it---is to retain a local San Francisco DUI lawyer who specializes in this field. Such a lawyer will know the ramifications of a DUI conviction and how the California DMV will treat a drunk driving conviction. If you have one or more prior convictions for DUI or DWI (some states refer to it as "driving while impaired"), you want an attorney who is knowledgeable about the ways to attack prior convictions and the adequacy of out-of-state convictions.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

When evaluating the constitutionality of a detention based on a tip to the police, one must preliminarily note the distinction between “anonymous tipsters” (folks who telephone the police about a crime, but do not identify themselves and are not known to the police), “government agents” (snitches working for the constable) and “citizen informants” (chance witnesses or crime victims who expose their identity). With regard to “anonymous tipsters” and “government agents,” there is no presumption of reliability attached to their reports. With “citizen informants,” however, there is a presumption of reliability, but even this presumption does not “dispense with the requirement that the informant—whether citizen or otherwise—furnish underlying facts sufficiently detailed to cause a reasonable person to believe that a crime had been committed....” People v. Ramey (1976) 16 Cal3d. 263, at 269.

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on January 31, 2011 in DUI

 This material is taken from California Drunk Driving Law (James Publishing), by Kuwatch, Burglin & Simons.  This is copyrighted material and may not be reprinted or published without written permission from James Publishing.

If you are a multiple offender interested in the possiblity of obtaining an IID restricted license as soon as possible, please contact San Francisco DUI Attorney Paul Burglin.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

IID-Restricted Licenses Available for Most Multiple Offenders After Just 12 Months, And Sooner For Some Second And Third Offenders

Effective January 1, 2006, multiple CVC § 23152 (non-injury) and § 23153 (with injury) offenders became eligible for an IID-restricted license after just 12 months of suspension, subject to various conditions and limitations.

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on January 12, 2011 in DUI

SAN FRANCISCO DUI LEGAL DEFENSES

There are various constitutional and statutory laws that can, in conjunction with the particular facts of criminal charge of drunk driving in California provide a compelling legal defense.

Here are a few of the possible factors that could help find you NOT GUILTY of driving under the influence:

• Did anybody see the car moving with you behind the wheel?
• Did you drive because there was some sort of emergency?
• Did somebody spike your drink with alcohol?
• Did you have an unanticipated reaction to prescribed medications?
• Was your performance on the field sobriety tests (FST’s) bad because of injury to your knees, back, joints or elsewhere?
• Were you asked to perform FST’s on something other than a flat, smooth, and well-lit surface?
• Do you suffer from diabetes or hypoglycemia?
• Did you have a fever during breath testing?
• Were you wearing removable dentures during breath testing?

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on January 06, 2011 in DUI

The unique aspect of California DUI prosecution in the City and County of San Francisco is that the potential for a good plea bargain is higher than in virtually any other Bay Area county. The reason for this is a mix of good liberal politics and a crowded court docket. Prosecutors at the San Francisco Hall of Justice recognize that drunk driving is not the crime of the century and they know that jurors in this great City tend to be more skeptical and questioning of police tactics and evidence.

The key to beating a DUI charge in San Francisco - or at least getting a reduced offer on it - is to retain a local lawyer who specializes in this field. Such a lawyer will know the ramifications of a DUI conviction and how the California DMV will treat a drunk driving conviction. If you have one or more prior convictions for DUI or DWI (some states refer to it as "driving while impaired"), you want an attorney who is knowledgeable about the ways to attack prior convictions and the adequacy of out-of-state convictions.

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on December 27, 2010 in DUI

Have you been charged with a DUI San Francisco, DUI Marin, DUI Sonoma or DUI Napa ? My name is Paul Burglin and I am a San Francisco Bay area drunk driving attorney who for over 25 years has specialized in drunk driving defense in San Francisco, Marin, Sonoma, Napa and surrounding communities. I am also the co-author of "California Drunk Driving Law".

Before hiring an attorney it is advisable to check their status and any history of license suspension history with the California State Bar (you can go to www.calbar.org and do an Attorney Search by name under the "Public" link). As reported by the California State Bar in the announcement below, a criminal defense attorney was recently disbarred for inappropriate sexual conduct with two clients. Your right to counsel in a criminal case includes the right to have an attorney who will defend you with integrity and professionalism.

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on November 24, 2010 in DUI

The San Rafael Police Department has scheduled another DUI and driver's license checkpoint in Marin County for this Wednesday, November 24th from 6 p.m. to 2 a.m. It will start on Freitas Parkway at Las Gallinas Avenue but will probably move to Irwin Street at Fifth Avenue later in the evening.

This law enforcement activity is funded by a Selective Traffic Enforcement Program (STEP) grant from the California Office of Traffic Safety, through the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

My Comments: I am not opposed to enforcement of the vehicle code and reasonable efforts to keep our community safe, but I am troubled by the warrantless detention of people without even probable cause to believe a violation of the law has been committed.

These “checkpoint" detentions involve uniformed police officers stopping citizens in the middle of the night and asking them where they have been and where they are going, and demanding identification (i.e., let me see your papers!). The mere odor of alcohol on your breath, though perfectly legal, prompts these officers to order you out of your car with a “request" that you perform coordination exercises on the side of the road. It’s supposedly just a request, but failure to adhere to it results in your immediate arrest for alleged suspicion of driving under the influence!

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on November 19, 2010 in DUI

LATEST UPDATE ON IID-RESTRICTED LICENSES: The DMV has now lost two separate lawsuits in Marin and Orange Counties based on its refusal to grant IID-restricted license (ignition interlock devices) to second-time DUI offenders with violation dates earlier than July 1, 2010, but with conviction dates subsequent to said date. A third lawsuit is reportedly now pending in Monterey County, wherein both the violation and conviction dates are prior to July 1, 2010. Notwithstanding the two losses, the DMV has yet to reverse its policy and will soon face additional lawsuits that include claims for attorney fees based on its arbitrary and capricious conduct. Clearly, the DMV is thumbing its nose at both the Legislature and the Courts, insisting upon a course of action that defies the legislative goal of encouraging DUI offenders to install ignition interlock devices in their vehicles. If you are a second or third time DUI offender interested in obtaining an IID-restricted license, contact San Francisco DUI attorney Paul Burglin today at (415) 453-0534.

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on October 30, 2010 in DUI

Mann County Superior Court Judge Verna A. Adams ruled in favor of a California man seeking the reinstatement of his driver’s lice nse following a second offense DUI conviction under law that went into effect on July 1, 2010. (client name redacted to preserve confidentiality)

40-year-old (name removed for confidentiality) was convicted of a second offense DUI on July 15, 2010, following his arrest on February 23, 2010. After having served 90 days of a license suspension, (name removed for confidentiality) sought the reinstatement of his license subject to his installing an ignition-interlock device (IID) in his vehicle. The IID prevents the operation of a vehicle if the driver has been drinking.

The DMV rejected (name removed for confidentiality) application for an IID-restricted license, contending that the new law does not apply to offenders with violation dates earlier than July 1, 2010. Finding that the legislative intent of the new law was to encourage all multiple offenders to install an IID in their car, Judge Adams ordered the DMV to grant (name removed for confidentiality) an IID ­restricted license.

Continue Reading ››

 Posted on July 15, 2010 in DUI

Have you been charged with a DUI San Francisco, DUI Marin, DUI Sonoma or DUI Napa ? My name is Paul Burglin and I am a San Francisco Bay area DUI defense attorney who for over 25 years has specialized in drunk driving defense in San Francisco, Marin, Sonoma, Napa and surrounding communities. I am also the co-author of "California Drunk Driving Law".

In this series of blog postings I am going to discuss search and seizure issues related to drunk driving cases. However, the totality of search and seizure law is perhaps as voluminous and complicated as drunk driving (DUI) law.

Hot Pursuit

Several California decisions have upheld the warrantless arrest of a DUI suspect where the act of driving was observed by the police and they entered his residence in “hot pursuit." See People v. Hampton (1985) 164 Cal.App.3d 27 (A short time after the arresting officer told the defendant not to drive, he saw a car like hers pull into her garage. He feared that she would drive again, having once done so after being warned); and People v. Lavoyne L.M. (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 154 (arrest in the defendant’s home for traffic infractions and driving without a license followed a hot pursuit that began in a public place).

Continue Reading ››